Recruiting guide

How good do you have to be to play in college? (by sport)

You have to be good enough for a level, not for Division I. In the NCAA's 2024-25 figures, 5.4% of high school boys in track and field go on to NCAA track, but only 1.9% compete in Division I, and most college athletes play in Division II, Division III, the NAIA or junior college. Here is what coaches measure in each sport and how to tell which level fits you.

By Kevin O'Brien, Co-founder of REACH

Updated November 17, 2026 · Checked against the NCAA's 2024-25 estimated probability of competing in college athletics on November 10, 2026

How many high school athletes play in college?

In the NCAA's 2024-25 figures, the share of high school athletes who go on to NCAA teams runs from about 4% in volleyball to about 15% in lacrosse. Far fewer play Division I: 3.4% in football, 2.7% in baseball and 2.1% in softball. NAIA and junior college teams add more spots on top.

High school athletes who go on to play NCAA sports, by sport (2024-25, percent)
Boys' lacrosse14.7%
Girls' lacrosse14.0%
Baseball8.8%
Football8.1%
Girls' cross country8.0%
Girls' soccer7.9%
Girls' track and field6.5%
Softball6.5%
Boys' soccer5.9%
Boys' track and field5.4%
Girls' volleyball4.0%

NCAA, Estimated probability of competing in college athletics (2024-25)

These are the NCAA's own participation estimates. They count only NCAA teams, so the real odds of playing somewhere in college are higher once you add the NAIA and junior colleges. How the five levels differ in money, time and rules is in D1 vs D2 vs D3 vs NAIA vs JUCO.

What do college coaches measure in each sport?

In timed and measured sports like track, cross country and swimming, coaches start with your marks. In team sports they start with film, then add size, verified measurables, the level of your club or high school competition and your grades. Every coach also wants to know you're coachable and how you compete.

What college coaches look at first, by sport (2026)
SportWhat coaches look at firstMore on it
Track and fieldEvent marks, with fully automatic times for sprintsHow to get recruited for track and field
Cross country5K and track times (1600m, 3200m) with the courseCross country recruiting steps
Swimming and divingTimes with the course (yards or meters); dive scores and videoYour times compared with each team's results
FootballFilm, then position size and verified measurablesFootball recruiting steps
Women's flag footballFilm by position, speed and handsWhat flag football coaches want on film
VolleyballFilm by position, height and reach for that positionVolleyball recruiting steps
LacrosseFilm and the level of your club teamLacrosse recruiting steps
SoccerGame film and the club league you play inCollege soccer recruiting steps
BaseballSkills video and measured numbers like velocity and the 60College baseball recruiting steps
SoftballSkills video, game film and your travel ball levelCollege softball recruiting steps

Numbers only help when someone can trust them. A hand time, a height you measured at home or a velocity from a backyard radar counts for less than a result from a meet, a camp or your coach.

How can you tell which college level fits you?

Compare yourself with the athletes already on college rosters at each level, not with the best player in the country. If your marks or film would put you in the middle of a team's roster, that level fits. If you'd be at the very bottom, look one level down, and if you'd lead the team, look up.

For track and field, every event is laid out by level on track and field recruiting standards, with recruit and walk-on marks. For team sports, look up two or three players at your position on each roster and watch their high school film if you can find it.

Fit is more than athletics. The school also has to admit you, offer what you want to study and cost what your family can pay after aid. How athletic scholarships work explains why most awards are partial and why Division III gives none.

Should you aim for Division I or play where you fit?

Aim where you fit, with a few stretch schools on top. Athletes who play at the right level usually get more time on the field, more coaching attention and often more aid. A list with realistic, stretch and long-shot schools gives you options without betting everything on one level.

Many athletes who were overlooked by Division I programs become starters and team leaders at Division II, Division III or NAIA schools. Development doesn't stop at 18, and some move up later through transfers. What matters now is getting in front of the coaches who would actually play you.

How REACH shows where you fit

REACH compares your marks, or your position and size, with college rosters level by level, then checks your grades against each school's admissions and shows your family's cost after aid. Every program gets one fit % with the reason behind it, split into realistic, stretch and long-shot schools.

Then it puts you in front of the coaches at those programs with a note written for each team, and nothing goes out until you approve it. REACH covers 1,210 colleges and 15,000+ coaches, is independent and not affiliated with the NCAA, NAIA or NJCAA, and is free to start.

Questions

Am I good enough to play D1?

Compare your marks or film with the athletes on Division I rosters at your position or event. If you'd sit in the middle of the roster, you have a real shot. Most college athletes play at other levels, and that is often the better fit.

Is it easier to play college lacrosse than college football?

By the NCAA's 2024-25 figures, a larger share of high school lacrosse players go on to NCAA teams (14.7% of boys) than football players (8.1%). The share at Division I is about the same, 3.4% in each.

Can you play in college if you're not a starter in high school?

Sometimes, especially at Division III, NAIA and junior college programs, or in sports with measured marks like track and swimming. Coaches care about what you can do and how fast you're improving.

Does Division III mean lower quality?

No. Division III has strong teams and serious athletes. It differs in money and time: there are no athletic scholarships, and seasons are shorter.

Sources: NCAA, Estimated probability of competing in college athletics (2024-25).

Keep reading

All guides